These
letters are absolutely fictional (to protect the innocent and
not-so-innocent.) But, with the hint of truth, maybe we can make some
adjustments. Principals have the best chance to do that.
Dear Principal,
When success becomes an 'anamoly' it is time to reassess what we are
doing as a school. The district benchmark for my ELA classes were
valid-as the second test deliberately given to 'show we cheated'-
demonstrated. The kids did great again. We didn't cheat, we worked
incredibly hard and no one should be shocked our 'demographic' can do
well. This is like a scene from "Stand and Deliver."' It frustrates and
frightens me that a District person would actually show up at your
office to complain about good testing. Exactly what do the district
people want? Stating that my benchmark test scores were an anamoly and
annual testing results like this would bring the inspectors suspiciously
down on us is a sorry attitude that squelches excellence. Our ELA 7th
Grade team here at -----Middle School had the best ELA team leader ever,
and I believe when we all do test at the end of the year, our ELA grade
level will show great improvement, even with the other teachers
administering the tests.
Signed,
Hurt and Frustrated Teacher
PS The kids were hurt the District thought they cheated.
Update: All the Grade Level ELA teams did do that year well, setting a
high standard that hasn't been matched (or even close) for 6 years.
5 Ways To Build a Culture of Collaboration with Staff, Teachers and Parents
Quick Guide to Teacher Team Building
My suggestion: When one teacher stands
out (in a positive way) the principal is like a parent that needs to
keep the family from jealousy and sniping. Principals have great
influence and can build teams of professionals that embrace other's
success (or lack thereof) with support and grace. The question of a
district that is suspicious of success reveals a greater, endemic
problem, a culture of failure that may minimize the students and
restrict achievement. Again, principals have opportunities to lead their
districts from a position of teacher support, innovation, and even
friendly competition between schools in the district. Success and
improvement should never be an anamoly but a goal.
Teachers punished for success, whether
it is in testing, parental relationships, or other arenas of education,
frequently just quit and start their own schools. But that is an unusual
option. Creating a success-friendly school culture is the best choice,
obviously.